Trust Is the New Differentiator in Executive Search
AI made knowledge abundant. What buyers of search should look for now.
This article draws on a Cornerstone International Group roundtable on earning the right to advise, featuring Antonio Cassano (Cornerstone International Italia), Samuel Dergel (Cornerstone Montreal), Dan Heiman (Global President, Cornerstone International Group), and Göran Jansson (Cornerstone Nordics), moderated by Larry Shoemaker (Vice Chairman, Cornerstone International Group). Client examples are shared with details withheld to protect confidentiality.
We used to hire for what people knew. Now, in the age of ChatGPT, knowledge is the cheapest thing in the room. Who knows our industry? Who knows our market? Who has the deepest network in our function? Those were sensible questions in a world where information was scarce and a good consultant could see parts of the market you could not.
That world is gone. Göran Jansson, Managing Partner of Cornerstone Nordics, points to a shift Cornerstone has watched happen in its own client research. A few years ago, when clients were asked what they valued most in a search partner, the top answer was knowing their business and their industry. Today the top answer is trust.
“AI has made knowledge abundant. Trust is now the scarce resource.” – Göran Jansson
The reason is simple. Any firm, and increasingly any tool, can produce an impressive industry analysis in seconds. Lists of qualified candidates are not hard to generate. What a tool cannot do is hold a confidential conversation, weigh a candidate against the specific moment your organization is in, or tell you something you do not want to hear because your interests require it.
You can’t prompt trust.
What judgment looks like in practice
In a recent search for a critical commercial role, Jansson’s team hit a wall every hiring committee will recognize. One candidate came out on top of every measure. Strong interviews, strong assessments, strong references. On paper, the decision was made.
But the consultants had spent enough time inside the client’s business to see something the scoring did not capture. Given where the company was in its life cycle, the moment called for humility rather than heroics. They recommended a different candidate, one who had not scored highest, and argued hard for the choice. The client hired that person. Six months later, the CEO told them the recommendation had saved the company from a very expensive mistake.
That is the difference between a vendor and an advisor. A vendor delivers the top of the list. An advisor is willing to put their credibility on the line when the list and the situation disagree.
Candor is the price of admission
Samuel Dergel, Managing Partner of Cornerstone Montreal, traces his strongest client relationships to the same behavior: telling clients the truth about what he sees, even when it is not what they hoped to hear. One of those relationships reached a turning point over lunch, when Dergel prefaced an observation with the words “as an outsider.” The CEO stopped him. “Samuel, you’re not an outsider. You’re an insider.”
That status is not granted quickly. Dan Heiman, Global President of Cornerstone International Group, describes a manufacturing client his firm has served for 25 years, a professionally managed family-owned business. The relationship began with a single HR search. Over time, through consistent work and some candid conversations about the market that were not always comfortable, it grew to include the entire executive suite.
“Every interaction is either a deposit or a withdrawal from your trust account.” – Dan Heiman
What this means for buyers of search
If knowledge is abundant and trust is scarce, the way you evaluate search firms should change. Polished market overviews and long client logos tell you less than they used to. Evidence of judgment and candor tells you more. Ask a prospective partner about a time they recommended against the obvious candidate, or advised a client not to proceed with a search at all. Ask them, as Dergel suggests, why their clients come back and why some do not. Then listen carefully to the answer.
The firms worth trusting will have real stories, told with the details protected.
The rest will have a pitch.
Cornerstone International Group is a global alliance of retained executive search and leadership consulting firms with 60+ offices in 40+ countries. To talk with a Cornerstone consultant about your next leadership decision, visit cornerstone-group.com.